财经市场
中期选举后,州政府与联邦政府在预测市场监管问题上的博弈愈发激烈。
中文译文
在中期选举之夜民主党人掌控了国会及多个重要州长职位之后,各州与联邦政府之间的权力斗争日益激烈。虽然人们普遍预计,如果民主党人赢得国会控制权,他们将会加强对这一新兴的、价值数十亿美元的行业的监管,但实际采取行动的却是以共和党为主导的各州。与此同时,负责监管预测市场的联邦机构——商品期货交易委员会,也加强了对“言论”市场的监管,这类市场里,交易者会猜测人们在演讲或广播中会说些什么。该机构称,这类事件合约容易受到操纵。CNBC周二首次报道称,CFTC在11月中旬因唐纳德·特朗普总统的言论而暂停了相关市场的认证。Kalshi表示正在遵守这一命令,但其首席执行官塔雷克·曼苏尔在周二的一次Axios活动中称,该公司不同意这一监管决定。
周四,参议院通过了一项两党共同提出的法案,该法案禁止CFTC注册的实体挂牌涉及恐怖主义、暗杀、战争或军事行动的合约。该法案还禁止那些“合理预期”会因某人死亡而了结的合约。
刑事指控、限制令及诉讼
犹他州总检察长德里克·布朗于10月28日对Kalshi及其创始人曼苏尔和卢安娜·洛佩斯·拉拉提出了14项刑事指控,称该公司违反了该州禁止赌博的法律。
根据法庭文件,Kalshi的创始人预计将于12月4日亲自出席犹他州第三区法院的庭审。“这简直是过度的干预行为;犹他州显然是在搞政治操弄。我们期待能像在亚利桑那州那样,通过法律手段制止这种行为,”卡尔希公司的发言人丹妮·莱弗说道。
在10月20日提交的另一份民事诉讼中,犹他州还将机构做市商Susquehanna International Group列为被告,与卡尔希公司一同被起诉。
尽管亚利桑那州总检察长克里斯·梅斯在3月对卡尔希公司提出了刑事指控,但一名联邦法官在4月阻止了该案件的进一步审理。
路易斯安那州的共和党州总检察长也在11月12日提交了诉讼,要求禁止多家交易平台在该州运营。同一天,一名州法官针对这些预测市场公司发布了临时禁令。“谁能想到,那些原本不愿卷入诉讼领域的红色州,最终却提出了最大胆、最具创新性的解决方案,”赌博行业律师丹尼尔·瓦拉赫说道。他指出,路易斯安那州和犹他州最新的诉讼是由共和党州检察长主导的。
作为回应,CFTC于11月13日对路易斯安那州提起了诉讼。此外,该联邦机构还在阿肯色州对卡尔希公司采取民事执法行动后,对该州也提起了诉讼。
CFTC已对12个州提起诉讼,试图维护其认为属于自己的、对预测市场进行监管的专属管辖权。
与此同时,CFTC可能很快会新增委员。唐纳德·特朗普总统于11月12日向美国参议院提交了跨党派提名,以填补该委员会四个空缺职位中的两个。自2025年12月其提名获得参议院批准以来,迈克尔·塞利格一直担任该委员会的唯一成员。共和党人内森·阿诺尼克和民主党人马修·罗兰德于周二在参议院农业委员会前作证。多名参议员就预测市场问题向他们提问。当被问及是否将体育相关赛事合同视为赌博时,两人均拒绝回答。
卡尔希在马里兰州败诉
本周,美国第四巡回上诉法院作出一项复杂的裁决,进一步削弱了CFTC的立场。该法院以2比1的投票结果裁定马里兰州可以依据其州赌博法对卡尔希采取行动,不过法官们在裁决理由上存在分歧。
卡尔希的发言人伊丽莎白·戴安娜在关于该裁决的声明中表示:“法官们甚至无法就我们为何犯错达成一致。这一分裂的裁决,包括三份相互矛盾的意见,表明目前并不存在针对预测市场的统一且连贯的法律论据。”总体而言,预测市场在地区法院层面的诉讼中已出现三场败诉和一场胜诉。人们普遍预计,关于各州或联邦政府是否有权监管与体育赛事相关的合同这一问题,最终将由最高法院作出裁决。
小唐纳德·特朗普与Kalshi终止合作
11月12日,Kalshi结束了与小唐纳德·特朗普的顾问关系。该预测平台指出,他的风险投资公司1789 Capital在竞争对手Polymarket中持有股份。
尽管1789 Capital早在8月就宣布了其在Polymarket中的持股情况,但在民主党在众议院和参议院获得多数席位后,Kalshi与这位总统的儿子终止了合作关系。预计民主党议员将会调查与特朗普家族有关联的公司。周一,由加利福尼亚州民主党参议员亚当·希夫领衔的九名民主党参议员致信美国商品期货交易委员会,要求其撤销一项指令——该指令要求相关平台在收到法院裁定禁止其在某些州开展业务时,不得对服务设置地域限制。
地域限制是指利用定位技术阻止特定辖区的用户参与相关合约交易。
这些参议员在信中写道:“你们的单方面决定与有效的法院命令直接冲突,削弱了州法和部落法律,必须予以撤销。”
与此同时,加利福尼亚州民主党众议员罗·卡纳呼吁国会全面禁止与体育相关的预测市场。
他在周三的X平台上发文称:“卡尔希这家价值400亿美元的公司允许18岁的年轻人参与体育博彩。他们称其为‘预测市场’,但实际上这就是赌博。应对其展开调查并予以禁止。”
披露:CNBC与卡尔希存在商业关系,包括客户引进业务以及少数股权投资。
原文
The turf war between states and the federal government is intensifying after Democrats secured control of Congress and key governorships on midterm elections night.
While it was widely expected Democrats would step up oversight of the emerging, multibillion-dollar industry if they won control of Congress, the actions after the elections have come from primarily Republican-led states.
At the same time, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission — the federal regulator for prediction markets — has ramped up its oversight of "mention" markets, where traders speculate on what individuals will say during a speech or broadcast. It's a type of event contract the agency has said is susceptible to manipulation.
CNBC first reported on Tuesday that the CFTC placed a hold on the certification of markets related to President Donald Trump's words in mid-November. Kalshi said it was complying with the order, but CEO Tarek Mansour said at an Axios event on Tuesday that the company disagreed with the regulatory decision.
On Thursday, the Senate passed a bipartisan bill that would ban CFTC-registered entities from listing contracts involving terrorism, assassination, war or military operations. The measure also bars contracts that are "reasonably expected" to resolve based on an individual's death.
Criminal charges, restraining order, lawsuits
Utah Attorney General Derek Brown filed 14 criminal charges against Kalshi and its founders, Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara, on Oct. 28, asserting the company violated a state law that prohibits gambling.
Kalshi's founders are expected to appear in person at Utah's Third District Court on Dec. 4, according to court documents.
"This is a crazy overreach; Utah is clearly playing politics. We look forward to putting a stop to this in court, just like we did in Arizona," said Kalshi's spokesperson Dani Lever.
In a separate, civil complaint on Oct. 20, Utah also named institutional market maker Susquehanna International Group as a defendant, along with Kalshi.
Though Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes filed a criminal complaint against Kalshi in March, a federal judge blocked the case from proceeding in April.
Louisiana's Republican attorney general also filed a complaint to ban multiple exchanges from operating in the state on Nov. 12. A state judge ordered a temporary restraining order against the prediction market companies that same day.
"Who would have thought that these red states, that were reluctant to jump into the litigation arena, ended up having the most boldest and most innovative solutions," said gambling attorney Daniel Wallach, noting that Louisiana and Utah's latest lawsuits were led by Republican attorneys general.
In response, the CFTC sued Louisiana on Nov. 13. Separately, the federal agency filed suit against Arkansas after that state pursued civil enforcement against Kalshi.
The CFTC has sued 12 states as it tries to defend what it views as its exclusive jurisdiction to regulate prediction markets.
Meanwhile, the CFTC may soon add commissioners. President Donald Trump sent bipartisan nominations to the U.S. Senate on Nov. 12 to fill two of the four open seats on the commission. Chairman Michael Selig has been the only member since his nomination was approved by the Senate in December 2025.
Nathan Anonick, a Republican, and Matthew Rowland, a Democrat, appeared before the Senate Agriculture Committee on Tuesday. Multiple senators questioned them on the issue of prediction markets. Both demurred when asked whether they viewed sports-related event contracts as gambling.
Kalshi loses in Maryland
The CFTC's position faced another setback in a complicated decision by the Fourth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals this week. The court ruled 2-1 that Maryland can enforce its state gambling law against Kalshi, though the judges disagreed on the reasoning.
"Judges can't agree with each other on why we're wrong," Kalshi spokesperson Elisabeth Diana said in a statement about the decision. "This splintered decision, including three separate contradictory opinions, demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets."
Overall, prediction markets have now seen three losses and one win at the circuit court level. It's widely expected the question of whether states or the federal government can regulate sports-related event contracts will be decided by the Supreme Court.
Donald Trump Jr. parts ways with Kalshi
Kalshi on Nov. 12 ended its advisory relationship with Donald Trump Jr. The prediction platform pointed to his venture capital firm 1789 Capital having a stake in rival platform Polymarket.
Though 1789 Capital announced its holding in Polymarket in August, Kalshi and the president's son ended their relationship after Democrats secured a majority in the House and Senate. Democratic lawmakers are expected to probe companies with relationships to the Trump family.
Nine Democratic senators, led by Adam Schiff, D-California, on Monday sent a letter to the CFTC asking it to reverse a directive to platforms not to geofence their offerings when they receive unfavorable court rulings stopping exchanges from operating in certain states.
Geofencing involves the use of location technology to block users in certain jurisdictions from participating in events contracts.
"Your unilateral decision directly conflicts with active court orders, undermines state and tribal law, and must be reversed," the senators wrote.
Meanwhile, Democratic Rep. Ro Khanna, D-California, has called for Congress to ban sports-related prediction markets entirely.
"Kalshi, a $40B company, lets 18 year olds bet on sports. They call it a 'prediction market.' It's gambling," he wrote in a post on X on Wednesday. "Investigate and ban sports prediction markets."
Disclosure: CNBC and Kalshi have a commercial relationship that includes customer acquisition and a minority investment.
