科技
为何世界仍在依赖未经验证的碳捕获技术?
中文译文
在航空订票屏幕、运输包装、电子产品以及食品货架上,我们都能看到这样的承诺:“碳中和”“净零排放”“符合气候承诺标准”。这些标签基于这样一个令人安心的前提:即便企业和国家继续燃烧化石燃料,只要捕获碳并将其封存起来,所产生的污染就能被抵消。
最近,我和ProPublica以及Drilled的同事们一起调查了为何世界会如此依赖这一前提,尤其是那种被称为碳捕获与封存的技术。碳捕获与封存旨在捕捉那些会加剧大气变暖的二氧化碳,并将其泵送到地球表面数千英尺深处,理想情况下,这些碳会一直留在那里。石油行业长期以来一直支持这一理念。
在该行业的推动下,联合国实际上也认可了这项技术可以在大规模范围内发挥作用这一观点。在过去的两周里,世界各国领导人和谈判代表齐聚土耳其安塔利亚,参加联合国年度重要气候峰会,各国在此商讨遏制全球变暖的承诺。这些谈判的核心基础——以及诸多碳中和目标与气候承诺——都建立在这样一种预期之上:我们每年能够封存数十亿吨二氧化碳,而这一规模在短短几十年内就能与当今全球整个石油产业相当。
然而我们的调查发现,这一预期缺乏充分依据。经过三十年的发展,至今仅有12个大规模地质储存项目建成,其中至少有7个项目表现不佳或失败了。去年,全球封存到地下的二氧化碳量还不到一座大型发电厂一年的排放量。
为什么世界各国领导人仍要将气候政策寄托在一种尚未得到验证的技术上?
因为他们所依赖的那些用于指导决策的模型,早已假定这项技术是可行的。为撰写这一系列文章,我与100多位专家进行了交流,其中包括那些负责构建和运行相关模型的强大团队中的数名成员。他们对经济和环境的模拟展示了诸如关闭燃煤电厂或为车辆配备电动动力系统等具体措施,如何避免出现足以淹没迈阿密等城市的灾难性气候变暖。这意味着,如果他们的预测有误,迈阿密可能会为此付出代价。
有一张图表清楚地显示了他们在碳捕获与封存技术方面的预测有多么错误。该图表将某一著名模型对碳捕获与封存技术的预测结果,与他们对太阳能技术的预测结果进行了对比——太阳能技术已经经过大量测试且效果显著,从最近的窗户向外看很可能就能看到太阳能电池板。
我想弄清楚究竟是什么导致了如此大的差异。但问题在于这些模型缺乏透明度:与大多数发表公开、经过同行评审研究的科学家不同,模型构建者无需记录他们在这些重要模拟中采用的每一个假设。于是我找到了全球三种最具影响力的气候模型的负责人——一种位于荷兰,另一种在德国,第三种在奥地利——并向他们提出了疑问。以下是我的了解:
气候模型认为捕获碳元素是简单且高效的。但事实并非如此。
公开数据很难获取,但多项分析表明,实际的捕获率远低于该行业所宣称的水平。然而这些模型计算的捕获率却高达92%。当我向负责奥地利模型的凯万·里亚希指出这一差异时,他坚称从工业排放中捕获高浓度二氧化碳“并非高技术含量,这非常容易做到”。里亚希告诉我,这些模型之所以假设较高的捕获率,是因为它们考虑了诸如碳税带来的收益以及巨额政府补贴等激励因素。他认为,如果加上这些激励措施,捕获率还会进一步提高。
但这些模型并未考虑到实际操作中会出现的问题。在一个又一个项目中,运营商们一直努力将尽可能多的碳注入地下,但实际效果并未如他们所宣称的那样。例如,在澳大利亚雪佛龙公司的戈尔贡天然气处理厂——这座工厂被誉为全球最大的碳捕获与封存设施——由于井眼堵塞和压力骤升,运营商们不得不将大部分二氧化碳直接排放到空气中。目前,只有由杰西卡·斯特雷弗勒提出的德国模式认为,运营商一次性注入地下的二氧化碳量是存在上限的。但她告诉我,目前并没有可靠的数据作为依据,她是根据对行业相关人员的“专家访谈”来估算这一上限的。
他们把地球当作一个无底洞般的地质填埋场。模型制作者们借鉴了2005年一份乐观的联合国报告,后来我得知该报告是应沙特阿拉伯及一些石油输出国的要求撰写的,报告中将地下储存空间描述为几乎无限。(联合国的气候科学机构表示仍支持这份报告。参与撰写报告的科学家们也为其工作进行了辩护。沙特阿美、雪佛龙和壳牌的作者及编辑与科学家们共同撰写了这份报告;这些公司并未回应置评请求。)然而就在去年,《自然》杂志上的一篇论文警告称,如果排除将碳捕获与封存气体注入城市下方、地震带以及海洋最深处的可能性,地球吸收此类气体的能力实际上可能要有限得多。该论文指出,如果碳捕获与封存真能像模型制作者设想的那样大规模实施,地球的储存空间可能在本世纪初就已耗尽。里阿希本人也是那篇论文的合著者,他承认,尽管他的模型假设地球的碳储存能力实际上是无限的,但实际潜力可能“更小”。
他们假设储存的二氧化碳会一直留在原地。
科学家们警告称,即便在较长的时间范围内每年只有微小的泄漏量,也可能削弱碳储存设施在气候方面的作用。我们的调查发现了两个出现泄漏的大规模储存设施,其中一个的二氧化碳甚至泄漏到了地表。这些模型肯定都考虑到了这种风险吧?我询问了荷兰模型的负责人德特莱夫·范·维伦,他的模型是否考虑了这一点。他只用一个词回答:“没有。”
这些模型都假设碳捕获与封存技术会随着时间变得更为经济实惠,而实际上其成本却在持续上升。当我问斯特雷弗勒,尽管如今各国政府都不愿投入一分钱来避免排放污染物,但认为我们的子孙后代会愿意支付巨额资金来从空气中去除二氧化碳是否有道理时,她表示:“如果一个国家都不愿意这么做,那我看不出他们怎么会愿意为二氧化碳去除技术付费。”
简而言之,这些建模专家忽视了数十年来该技术表现不佳的事实、被高估的捕获率、存在泄漏现象以及地下储存空间有限等问题,同时还假设未来几代人会愿意为这个成本日益上升的行业提供资金支持。他们引用了各种经过验证的研究来支持自己的观点,同时也提到了未经审核的白皮书、与行业内部人士的随意交谈,以及范·维伦作为作者之一参与的2005年联合国报告。范·维伦称,他的团队正在努力修正部分假设,但他总体上认为从技术层面来看,碳捕获与封存技术并非行不通,也不应被排除在他所设计的模型所考虑的各种可能性之外。他说,各国是否愿意投入资金和精力来实现这一目标,这是一个政策决策。
看待模型预测的一种方式是将其视为未来的“食谱”。从这种角度来看,模型制作者的立场是,他们的任务是编写一本食谱,而非告诉我们每道菜的味道如何。换句话说,这些模型仅仅表明,如果碳捕获与封存技术能够发挥作用并且得到大规模应用,就有可能实现气候目标。模型制作者们向ProPublica和Drilled表示,由于在气候行动方面存在延误,已经几乎没有其他方法可以实现这一目标——因此他们才将碳捕获与封存技术纳入考量。
不过,一份好的食谱不能依赖虚构的食材。我半开玩笑地问里亚希,如果我们做出了不切实际的假设,为何不考虑外星人出现并为我们提供解决气候变化方法的可能性呢?
“你可以引用我的话,我认为二氧化碳去除技术比外星人出现更有可能实现,”里亚希说道。
原文
You see the promise on airline booking screens, shipping boxes, electronics and grocery aisles: “Carbon neutral.” “Net zero.” “Climate pledge friendly.” Those labels rest on the comforting premise that even when companies and countries keep burning fossil fuels, the resulting pollution can be canceled out by simply capturing the carbon and locking it away.
Recently, along with my colleagues at ProPublica and Drilled, I investigated how the world came to rely so heavily on this premise, particularly in the technology known as carbon capture and storage. CCS aims to trap carbon dioxide that would otherwise be warming the atmosphere and pump it thousands of feet below Earth’s surface, where, ideally, it stays put. The oil industry has long favored the idea.
At the industry’s prodding, the United Nations has effectively endorsed the idea that the technology can work at a massive scale.
Over the last two weeks, world leaders and negotiators met in Antalya, Turkey, for the U.N.’s annual flagship climate summit, where nations hash out global commitments to curb warming. A central foundation of these negotiations — and many of those carbon-neutrality labels and climate pledges — is the expectation that we can bury billions of tons of CO2 a year, an operation that would rival today’s entire global oil industry within just a couple of decades.
Yet our reporting found that expectation rests on thin evidence. After three decades of development, only 12 large-scale geologic storage projects have ever been built, and at least seven have underperformed or failed. Last year, the world buried less CO2 underground than a single large power plant emits annually.
Why do world leaders keep staking climate policy on a technology that remains unproven?
Because the models they all rely on to guide their approach have already presumed that it will work.
I spoke to more than 100 experts for this series, including several members of the wildly powerful group of people who build and run those models. Their simulations of the economy and environment map out how specific choices, like retiring coal plants or electrifying vehicles, could prevent warming catastrophic enough to submerge cities like Miami. Which means that if they’re wrong, Miami could pay the price.
One chart laid bare to me exactly how wrong they’ve been about CCS. It compares one prominent model’s projections for CCS with their projections for solar power, a technology so abundantly tested and proven that you can likely spot a panel out the nearest window:
I wanted to understand what could possibly account for such a disparity. But the problem is the models are opaque: Unlike most scientists, who trade in public, peer-reviewed studies, modelers aren’t required to document every assumption they build into their influential simulations.
So I tracked down the leaders of the world’s three most influential climate models — one based in the Netherlands, another in Germany and a third in Austria — and asked. Here’s what I learned:
Climate models assume it’s easy and efficient to capture carbon. It’s not.
Public data is hard to come by, but several analyses have found the real capture rates are far lower than the industry has promised. Yet the models calculate as much as a 92% success rate. When I pointed out this discrepancy to Keywan Riahi, who leads the Austrian model, he insisted that capturing concentrated CO2 from industrial emissions “is not high-tech, this is very easy to do.” Riahi told me the models assume a high rate of capture because they factor in incentives such as payouts from carbon taxes and large government subsidies. Add those incentives, he argues, and the capture rates would increase.
They don’t account for problems that come up in real-world practice.
In project after project, operators have struggled to inject as much carbon into the earth as they say they can. For instance, at Chevron’s Gorgon natural gas processing plant in Australia, billed as the largest CCS operation on Earth, clogged wells and pressure spikes have forced operators to release most of their CO2 straight into the air. As it stands, only the German model, led by Jessica Strefler, assumed there’d be any limit to how much CO2 operators could inject underground at once. But, she told me, there is no good data to work from, and she pegged the limit based on “expert interviews” with people in the industry.
They assume the Earth is a bottomless geologic landfill.
Modelers took that cue from a rosy 2005 U.N. report, which I’d learned had been written at the behest of Saudi Arabia and allied petrostates, that portrayed underground storage space as practically limitless. (The U.N.’s climate science body has said it stands by the report. Scientists who contributed to the report also defended their work. Authors and editors from Saudi Aramco, Chevron and Shell joined scientists in writing it; the companies did not respond to requests for comment.) Yet just last year, a paper in the journal Nature warned that the earth’s capacity to absorb CCS could be far more limited once you rule out pumping the gas beneath cities, into earthquake zones and under the deepest parts of the oceans. If CCS ever worked at the scale modelers imagine, the paper found, the Earth could run out of room as soon as early next century. Riahi, himself a co-author on that paper, conceded that although his model presumes the earth’s capacity for carbon storage is literally infinite, the real potential may be “smaller.”
They assume that stored CO2 will stay put.
Scientists warn that even tiny annual leak rates over longtime horizons could undermine a storage site’s climate benefit. Our investigation found two large-scale sites that have leaked, one all the way to the surface. Surely the models all factor in this risk? I asked Detlef van Vuuren, leader of the Dutch model, if his did so. His one-word answer: “Nope.”
The models all assume CCS gets more affordable over time, though real-world costs have steadily climbed.
When I asked Strefler if it makes sense to assume our children and grandchildren will pay big bucks to suck CO2 out of the air, even though today governments won’t spend pennies to avoid emitting that pollution, she said: “If a country is not willing to do that, I don’t see how they would be willing to” pay for CO2 removal.
In short, the modelers overlooked decades of underperformance, inflated capture rates, evidence of leaks and finite underground storage, all while assuming future generations will willingly bankroll an increasingly expensive industry. They pointed to a mix of legitimate studies to support those assertions. They also pointed to unreviewed white papers, casual chats with industry insiders and the 2005 U.N. report — of which van Vuuren was an author. Van Vuuren said his team is working to revise some of its assumptions, but he generally sees no technical reason why CCS cannot work, or should be excluded from the possibilities his model considers. He said it is a policy decision whether countries wish to invest the dollars and effort to make it happen.
One way to look at the model projections is as recipes for the future. Seen this way, the modelers’ argument is that their job is to assemble a cookbook, not tell us how each recipe tastes. In other words, the models merely show that if CCS works and is used at an extraordinary scale, it is possible to hit climate targets. And the modelers told ProPublica and Drilled that the delay in climate action has left few other tools to do so — and so they include CCS.
A good recipe, though, cannot rely on imaginary ingredients. If we’re making unrealistic assumptions, why not include the possibility that aliens will appear and hand us a solution to climate change, I asked Riahi, half joking.
“You can quote me that I think carbon dioxide removal is more likely than an alien,” Riahi said.