科技
在人工智能能够解决数学问题的这一年里,一位Anthropic公司的员工称自己可能已经破解了最难的难题。
中文译文
An Anthropic公司的一名员工兼数学家声称,他利用该公司的人工智能聊天机器人证明了著名的黎曼假设。在Anthicorp首次在美国股市上市后的第二天,即周五,Levent Alpöge表示,他在大约六周的时间里使用Claude聊天机器人完成了这个数学问题的详细证明。如果该证明被证实正确,它将成为历史上最重要的证明之一。Alpöge将其描述为“科学领域中一次迈向更伟大事物的曙光”。这一声明出现之际,像OpenAI这样的人工智能公司近几个月来也宣布找到了许多困扰学者数十年的重大高等数学问题的解决方案。至于周五提出的黎曼假设证明,它是使用Anthicorp的Claude的非公开版本完成的。这是一个已有近170年历史的数学问题,涉及素数,由于其复杂性,它被广泛认为是数学领域中最著名的问题。这一假设以数学家伯恩哈德·黎曼的名字命名,其观点认为质数在数轴上具有确定的排列顺序。
质数是高等数学的基石,与之相关的突破往往能产生深远影响。
阿尔珀格表示,他在周日给Anthropic的首席执行官达里奥·阿莫代发了消息,直接询问该如何宣布这一发现。
“确切的时机实在糟糕,”阿尔珀格在谈到Anthropic的公开上市时说道,“如果可以的话,我早就把这一切处理完了。”
“显然,我独自承担着那种感觉——再等待下去我就无法忍受了。虽然有人从时机上给出了一些愤世嫉俗的看法,但那是错误的,”他补充道。
阿尔珀格用用于验证数学证明的计算机语言Lean所提交的完整文本证明长达25万页以上。
著名数学家陶哲轩在周五表示,要验证这一证明还有很长的路要走。“我认为消化这个过程需要一些时间,不过至少在这次情况下,我们有可以沟通的人类专家来协助完成这项任务,”陶说道。
显然,在今年早些时候利用人工智能完成的重大数学证明中,并没有人类参与。
OpenAI在9月声称,其员工使用未公开的AI工具版本,仅用88小时就解决了一个极为复杂的问题的部分内容。该问题属于描述流体运动的纳维-斯托克斯方程的一部分。
作为一项人工智能训练练习,超过10,000个AI智能体,即能够一定程度上自主运行的计算机程序化机器人,被用于解决这一任务。
OpenAI发布的关于纳维-斯托克斯方程的证明尚未得到准确性验证,这一成果引发了学术界及高等数学界对利用人工智能解决数学问题的批评。
Anthropic也声称在数学和物理学领域取得了其他进展和解决方案。一群数学学者表示,那些宣称已找到重大解决方案以展示其商业产品有多先进的AI公司,其行为“对数学科学有害”。
这些学者在一份联名信中写道:“我们正目睹智力劳动面临普遍威胁,因为AI应用的结果与其最初目的之间存在偏差。”
一个月后,OpenAI宣称已为另外372个高难度高等数学问题找到了解决方案、证明或取得了重大进展。
即便专家们开始对这些宣称进行验证,也需要数月时间,甚至更久才能确定其真实性。
原文
An Anthropic employee and mathematician claims to have used the company's artificial intelligence (AI) chatbot to prove the famed Riemann hypothesis.
Levent Alpöge said on Friday, a day after Anthropic made its US stock market debut, that over the course of about six weeks, he used the Claude chatbot to create a detailed proof of the maths problem.
If found to be correct, the proof would be among the most significant in history. Alpöge described it as "one dawn across science of something far greater".
The claim comes as AI firms like OpenAI have in recent months announced scores of solutions to major higher maths problems that have eluded scholars for decades.
As for the Riemann hypothesis proof put forward on Friday, it was found using a non-public version of Anthropic's Claude.
It is a nearly 170-year-old maths problem that deals with prime numbers and is widely considered to be the single most famous problem in maths, in large part due to how complex it is.
Named for the mathematician Bernhard Riemann, the hypothesis puts forward that prime numbers have a determined order along the number line.
Prime numbers are the bedrock of higher maths, leaving breakthroughs related to them to have broad impact.
Alpöge said that he messaged Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei on Sunday, asking him directly about how he could announce the discovery.
"The precise timing is horrible," Alpöge said, referring to Anthropic's public stock listing. "If I could have, I'd have finished this all much earlier."
"I am clearly unilaterally responsible for feeling I just could not live if I waited even longer. There is an obvious cynical view, to do with the timing, but it is false," he added.
The complete textual proof that Alpöge put forward in Lean, a computer language used for confirming maths proofs, is over 250,000 pages long.
Terrance Tao, a prominent mathematician, said on Friday that verification of the proof is still some way off.
"I imagine the digestion process will take some time, though in this case at least we have a human author to communicate with to assist with this task," Tao said.
No such human was obviously a part of major maths proofs made earlier this year using AI.
OpenAI in September claimed that employees using a non-public version of its AI tools were able to solve part of a notoriously difficult problem in just 88 hours. The problem was part of the Navier-Stokes equations, which concern how fluids move.
More than 10,000 AI agents, or computer programmed bots that operate somewhat autonomously, were put to the task as an AI training exercise.
The proof that OpenAI released on Navier-Stokes has yet to be confirmed as accurate, and it set off criticism within academic and higher maths communities and organisations about the use of AI to solve maths problems.
Anthropic has also claimed to have made other progress and solutions in maths and physics.
A group of maths scholars said AI companies boasting of major solutions to show how sophisticated their commercial products had become was "detrimental to the science of mathematics".
"We are witnessing a general threat to intellectual work, with misalignment between the outcome of the use of AI and its initial purpose," the scholars said in a group letter.
A month later, OpenAI released what it claimed were solutions, proofs, or major progress on 372 more outstanding higher maths problems.
It will take months, if not longer, for those claims to be reviewed by experts to prove their validity.